|
|
At the root of it all
Barometric body blues
It's changing weather, not hot, cold or clouds, that
makes you ache
By ELIZABETH BROMSTEIN |
|
We've had lots of weather lately, haven't we? That's my favourite
ice breaker. But seriously, folks, it was friggin' hot for
a couple of days.
I hate hot, and I hate humid even more. I can't eat when
it gets that way. I can't sleep. I'm a mess.
Many of us are convinced that what's doing in the atmosphere
has an effect on our health and well-being beyond the obvious,
from people like me who waste away in the heat to Grandma
and her throbbin' toe that tells ya when a storm is a comin'.
Many a chronic pain sufferer claims that air pressure and
humidity affect how they're feeling even though the scientific
data is spotty.
One study discovered that it's actually changes in the weather
and not a specific kind of weather that causes discomfort.
The body, it seems, adjusts to particular temperatures and
moisture levels, and any shift forces tissues to readjust,
triggering the nerves that signal pain. All this means that
a cold spell in Florida may hurt as much as a change of clime
in T.O., so don't assume you're a jet-ride from relief.
Then there's the suggestion that meteorology can explain
the particular effects on the fetus that lead to larger risks
for mental illness.
What the experts say
"Research suggests that adverse environmental factors
during gestation or around the time of birth may disrupt normal
brain development, and that may increase a child's chances
of developing a mental illness. Temperature extremes can be
stressful and weaken the immune system. Research also indicates
that vitamin D deficiency can be a problem, and we get most
of ours from sunlight. It's been found that people with schizophrenia
are more likely to be born at certain times of the year, specifically
winter and early spring. The risk is still small, and the
take-home lesson should be for expectant mothers in general
to be given optimal care."
DENNIS KINNEY , associate professor of psychology, Harvard
Medical School, Boston
"Hot weather is more yang, cold wea-ther more yin. One
of the most important things to do with changing weather is
to eat differently. Meat is hot, grains are neutral and fruits
and vege-tables are cold. Eat more meat in colder weather,
and vegetables and fruit in the warmer weather. In hot, humid
weather you need spicy food to unclog dampness that can cause
the digestive system or joints not to work well. You can get
headaches, cloudy thinking, urination problems and your menstrual
cycle or bowel movements can get screwed up. There are no
vegetarian cultures in the far north, but you can be a vegetarian
in India, no problem.''
KALEB MONTGOMERY , Chinese medicine practitioner, Toronto
"Our study tried to show whether people who think weather
affects their migraines are accurate. We found that they are
not completely accurate. Approximately 65 per cent said they
were affected and 51 per cent were correct. What's affecting
them varies in different patients. You can't say that everyone
is going to get a migraine when it's hot and humid. People
exposed to very low temperatures had worse migraines than
those exposed to high temperatures, which surprised us. Another
factor was change from hot to cold, cold to hot or changes
in barometer from a clear, beautiful day to a bad day. [Some
people were influenced by] absolute barometric pressure on
days when the barometer was really low or even when it was
really high. If you can determine the factor that bothers
you, you can prepare.
ALAN RAPOPORT , director, New England Center for Headache,
professor of neurology, Columbia University, New York City
"We gave questionnaires to hundreds of chronic pain
patients in several different locations, and most said weather
changes affected them. I was surprised at how little research
has been done on the subject, but that may be because people
feel nothing can be done about it. The body consists of nerves,
tendons, bones and a whole bunch of water. We know some of
these tendons move with damp, moist conditions, similar to
what leather does in terms of moisture in the air. Any stretching
or change in musculature may trigger pain. Cold has an effect
on pain. People with arthritis report high incidences of weather-affected
pain, as do those with back surgeries or other kinds of nerve
damage. These reactions are not limited to humans. In some
places people know it's going to rain when cockroaches start
flying or cows lie down."
ROBERT JAMISON , associate professor in anesthesia and psychiatry,
Harvard Medical School
"The surprising thing is that more people die of heat
in Toronto than in Phoenix, Arizona. The structures in Phoenix
where poor people live are much more amenable to the heat.
The poor live in places with shiny roofs, made of frame stucco.
In Toronto, Chicago and New York, they live in red brick houses
with black tar roofs that absorb heat. People there aren't
used to extreme heat waves. Heat causes respiratory failure,
cardiac arrest or stroke, but these are never classified as
heat-related. You don't know why the person got a heart attack,
but they happen much more frequently during heat waves."
LARRY KALKSTEIN , senior research fellow, University of Delaware,
Centre of Climatic Research, Florida
NOW | JUNE 8 - 14, 2006 | VOL. 25 NO. 41

|